Brought to you by Audacious Nimby
Prince William County, Virginia

Save our property rights. All of them. Including your neighbor's.

We love property rights. That's exactly why we take them seriously. Your rights are real, they are valuable, and they stop at the property line. A request to rezone farmland for thousands of homes isn't a property right. It's a request for new ones, paid for by everyone next door.

The Board of County Supervisors takes up Item 12-D on Tuesday, November 17, 2026 at 2 p.m. Online written comments close at 1:05 p.m. that day.
What Item 12-D actually does

A plan to keep rural Gainesville rural, and make it pay

Supervisor George Stewart's Heritage Tourism & Recreation Small Area Plan asks the County to plan this corner of the Gainesville District as a whole, around what's already here: farms, forests, streams and the Manassas battlefield. Instead of deciding the area's future one developer application at a time, it sets a shared direction everyone can see and weigh in on.

๐ŸŒพ

Keeps the land A-1

The area keeps its existing agricultural and forestry designations, and A-1 zoning stays in place: one home per 10 acres, exactly as today. Nobody's land is rezoned, and nobody's home-building rights shrink.

๐Ÿ’ง

Protects the watershed

No extension of public water and sewer into the rural area, except in very limited cases. Existing tree canopy is kept and paving is kept to a minimum, because the streams here feed the Occoquan Reservoir and the wells rural families drink from.

๐Ÿ‡

Brings in the right businesses

New commercial activity is aimed at heritage tourism, recreation and agritourism: wineries, farm stores, pick-your-own fields, trails, event barns and battlefield visitors. These are businesses that fit A-1 land, need little new infrastructure, and build on the County's existing Agritourism and Arts Overlay District.

๐ŸŒ™

Guards the setting

Dark-sky lighting standards keep nights dark next to a national battlefield, and the plan's approach protects the scenic, historic character that heritage visitors come to see.

Why it matters for landowners: a farm, winery or venue that draws visitors earns income from the land while keeping it land. That's a property right put to work: more ways to profit from rural acreage, without paving it, and without passing the costs to the neighbors.

Item 12-D: the attacks

The "property rights" attack on the rural plan, answered

An anonymous website is urging residents to oppose Item 12-D, Supervisor George Stewart's proposed Gainesville District Heritage Tourism & Recreation Small Area Plan. It claims that tens of thousands of residents are about to lose their property rights. Here is what it says, and what's actually true.

They sayThousands of residents will lose their property rights through this directive.

A small area plan is a plan, not a rezoning. Small area plans don't change anyone's existing zoning. They're a blueprint for how the County will evaluate future requests. Your A-1 rights the day after the vote are exactly what they were the day before.

Any real change has to come back to you. Under Virginia law, changing a zoning map requires at least two public hearings, one before the Planning Commission and one before the Board, with legal notice to affected owners. A directive to study an area takes nobody's land.

They sayThe plan sets a 40-acre minimum parcel size.

It doesn't. The 40-acre figure isn't in the directive before the Board. Their own page sources it to a July 10 working-group slide deck, an early brainstorm months before the directive was written.

Even there, it wasn't about your house lot. It came from early thinking about the site size one kind of business the plan hopes to attract might need, such as a heritage tourism or recreation venue. Setting a minimum site size for a specific commercial use is ordinary zoning. It says nothing about how many homes you can build.

Your residential rights don't change. A-1 still allows one home per 10 acres, and nothing in Item 12-D changes that.

They saySpecial interest groups wrote it, and landowners were shut out.

Look at who they call "special interests": residents of the district, local conservation nonprofits, and battlefield and national park groups. Citizens bringing ideas to their own supervisor is how local government is supposed to work.

Compare that with what landowners faced this summer: two assemblages asking to put about 3,900 homes on rural land, filed over County staff's objection. Residents at that hearing raised concerns that the same land agent was behind both projects and the failed Digital Gateway. A study the whole public can weigh in on is the open process. Parcel-by-parcel amendments are the closed one.

They sayThe County's own planners objected.

They did, and it's worth reading what they objected to: scope, length, how prescriptive the draft was, and staff workload. Those are fair drafting critiques, and the answer is to fix the directive's scope. They aren't findings that planning for the rural area is a bad idea.

The same Planning Office recommended against both of this summer's rural housing amendments. If staff judgment matters, it matters both times.

They sayKeeping the tree canopy means the County controls your trees.

Forests are the watershed's filter. The County's adopted Comprehensive Plan already recognizes existing forests as important for protecting water quality. Canopy goals are about clearing land for development.

Farm woodlots are protected by state law. Virginia Code ยง 10.1-1126.1 already bars localities from prohibiting or unreasonably limiting bona fide forestry done under state best management practices. No county plan can override that.

They say"Minimal impervious surfaces" is a way to stop development.

Pavement doesn't keep its runoff to itself. Research cited by the Prince William Conservation Alliance finds streams become impaired when just 10% of a watershed is covered in impervious surface.

This is drinking water. The Occoquan Reservoir serves about 800,000 Northern Virginians, and roughly 40% of its watershed lies in Prince William County. The County's adopted plan already says to minimize impervious surface in new development.

They sayThe lighting standards came from someone who owns a lighting company.

They came from someone who knows lighting. The lighting input came from Patrick Harders, LC, a certified lighting designer with 29 years of experience, 15 years in fixture manufacturing, and a long record of leading dark-sky and light-trespass training programs. That's exactly who you want helping write lighting standards: someone who knows how to keep light where it belongs.

Dark-sky standards set outcomes, not brands: fully shielded fixtures, light aimed down, warmer color temperatures, and lights off when no one needs them. Any manufacturer's fixture can meet them, and many of the cheapest already do.

The issue is the neighbors. Light trespass is, by definition, light that crosses the property line. Next to a national battlefield, keeping the night sky dark is a heritage-tourism asset. The County's own Planning Commission has already recommended dark-sky lighting improvements on new development.

They say"Approved businesses only": heritage tourism, recreation and agritourism.

Every land-use map already picks. That's what designations are. The only question is whether the choice is made openly in a plan or quietly one application at a time.

The County is already headed there. In September the Board voted 8-0 to end by-right data center development countywide, and the County has commissioned a study toward a 10-year plan for its farm and agritourism economy. Wineries, farms and farm stores fit rural Gainesville. Industrial campuses don't.

Notice the pattern: every rule they object to protects someone else's water, sky, road or land. That's not taking property rights. It's protecting them.

The oldest rule in property law

"Use your own property in such a way that you do not injure another's."

Sic utere tuo ut alienum non laedas. English and American courts have been applying it for centuries.

Property rights were never a license to do anything you want. From the start, they came with a built-in limit: your use of your land can't take away your neighbor's use of theirs.

That's why you can't dam the creek that feeds the farm downstream, pump the shared aquifer dry, or point a stadium light into the bedroom window across the road. Nuisance law came first. Zoning came later, as a way to settle those conflicts before the damage is done instead of in court after.

So when someone says "it's my land, I can do what I want," the honest answer is: you can, right up to the point where it becomes your neighbor's problem.

What you actually own

Ownership is a bundle of sticks. Every stick has fine print.

Lawyers describe property as a "bundle of rights." When you bought your land, you bought the bundle as it existed that day, including the zoning that came with it.

PossessionIt's yours. Your name is on the deed.
Taxes still due.
ControlUse it how you choose.
Within the law and the zoning you bought.
EnjoymentPeaceful use, free from interference.
Your neighbors get this one too.
ExclusionKeep others out.
Traffic, runoff and glare don't knock first.
DispositionSell it, lease it, leave it to your kids.
The buyer gets the same bundle you had.
1 : 10

The stick you actually bought. Most undeveloped land in the county's Rural Area is zoned A-1, Agricultural, which allows one house per 10 acres. The 1998 plan that set the 10-acre minimum matched the zoning most of those parcels already had. Nobody was downzoned. That right is still there today, untouched.

Interactive

The Property Rights Calculator

Enter a parcel's acreage and the number of homes an applicant is asking for. We'll show you how much of that request is a right they already own, and how much is a new right they're asking the public to hand over.

50
homes allowed by right today
1,150
homes that are a new request
24ร—
more than the rights they own
Owned by rightRequested from the public

Simplified for illustration: by-right yield on a real parcel also depends on roads, floodplain, perc, and rural cluster options. Each square represents one home (display capped at 1,200). Case acreage and maximum home counts are as reported by the Prince William Times and InsideNoVa, July 2026.

Over the fence

Things that don't stay on your side of the property line

A thousand new rooftops on one parcel is not a private decision. These are the costs that cross the fence, and the people who pay them never got a vote at the closing table.

๐Ÿ’ง

Groundwater

Rural families drink from wells that share an aquifer. Pave the recharge area or draw it down, and the neighbor's well is the one that goes dry.

๐ŸŒง๏ธ

Stormwater

Rain that used to soak into pasture now sheets off roofs and driveways and lands on whoever is downhill. Water always finds the neighbor.

๐Ÿš—

Roads

Country roads were built for country traffic. Thousands of daily trips don't stay on the developer's land. They use your road, your intersection, your commute.

๐Ÿซ

Schools & services

New homes need classrooms, fire coverage and ambulances. If the project doesn't pay for them, every taxpayer in the county does.

๐ŸŒ™

The night sky

Streetlights and parking lots don't stop at the property line either. Light trespass and skyglow turn a dark rural night into a permanent dusk for miles.

๐Ÿ›๏ธ

Shared heritage

Battlefields, historic roads and scenic corridors belong to everyone. Some things, once paved, don't come back.

Not hypothetical

The two cases on the table right now

On July 21, 2026, the Board of County Supervisors voted 5-3 to initiate two Comprehensive Plan Amendments in the rural Gainesville District, next to Manassas National Battlefield Park. Initiation is not approval. It starts a study, and more votes are still required. But the Board did it over the objection of the County's own planning staff, who recommended against both.

CPA2026-00016

"Manassas Preserve"

General Trimbles Lane, on the battlefield's western edge. Owners assembled their land to sell to a developer for a 55-and-over community.

~256acres
2,762homes requested
~25homes by right at 1 per 10 acres
121 โ†’ 6,000+daily vehicle trips, per County staff estimate

Staff found the proposed density conflicts with the land's existing Agricultural/Forestal and Parks & Open Space designations, and flagged compatibility, transportation and infrastructure concerns next to the battlefield.

CPA2026-00003

Catharpin Valley Estates

Along Catharpin Road. An existing neighborhood of 30 homes on 30 lots, where residents filed so a developer could buy and redevelop the whole thing.

~293acres
1,167homes requested
30homes there today
~39ร—today's home count

Staff said even a reduced density would not meaningfully lessen the traffic impact on Catharpin Road or the environmental impact on Lick Branch.

Here's the property-rights point. Every one of these owners has the right to sell, and nobody here begrudges them a good price. What's being asked for is something else: roughly 3,900 homes on about 550 acres where the rights on the books allow about 55. The difference isn't something they own. It's something the public would be handing them.

Opponents at the hearing asked for a groundwater study before anything moves forward. That's not obstruction. Rural neighbors drink from wells. Find out what the aquifer can carry before you decide how many straws to put in it.

A better way

Plan first. Then decide. Grow where the pipes and roads already are.

Saying no to sprawl isn't saying no to growth. Prince William County already has tools, and serious proposals, for growing in the right places while paying rural landowners fairly and protecting the people next door.

Supervisor George Stewart

A Heritage Tourism & Recreation Small Area Plan (Item 12-D)

Instead of deciding the future of rural Gainesville one developer application at a time, Gainesville Supervisor George Stewart has proposed a dedicated small area plan for the district's rural heritage corridor, built around heritage tourism, recreation and agriculture. It comes before the Board as Item 12-D on November 17, 2026.

Small area plans are how the County does detailed, place-by-place planning: a shared vision, design guidelines, an economic analysis, and a check on whether roads, schools and services can keep up. At the July vote, Chair Deshundra Jefferson made the same case: pause and create a plan for the area first.

Prince William Conservation Alliance

The 3Rs: Reimagine, Reinvest, Redevelop

Reimaginewhat our existing places could become
Reinvestin neighborhoods and corridors already built
Redeveloptired, underused commercial land

PWCA's framework steers growth toward the county's suburban and urban cores, where reinvestment can build walkable, mixed-use communities, while the rural area, forests and drinking-water sources stay protected. As PWCA puts it, we don't have to choose between growth and conservation.

Prince William County

Purchase of Development Rights

A voluntary program where the County buys a property's residential development rights and records a permanent open-space easement. The landowner keeps the land and gets paid. That's preservation that respects property rights instead of overriding anyone's.

Rural economy

Agritourism, not asphalt

Farms, wineries, pick-your-own fields and farm stores bring visitors and revenue to rural Prince William without new sewer lines or widened roads. The Coalition to Protect Prince William County warns that rural housing sprawl would undercut both the PDR program and this agritourism economy.

Myth vs. fact

Things you may have heard

Saying no to a rezoning takes nothing away. You keep every right you bought: the house, the farm, the ability to sell, the one-home-per-10-acres yield. A denied application leaves you exactly where you started.

What a rezoning does is add value by granting new density. Declining to give someone something new is not taking something they had.

You can, and nobody on this site says otherwise. Sell to a farmer, a family, a land trust, or a developer. The buyer simply gets the same bundle of rights you had. What you can't do is sell rights you don't own yet and expect the neighbors to make up the difference.

Prince William County now runs a voluntary Purchase of Development Rights (PDR) program. The County buys a parcel's residential development rights and records a permanent open-space easement. You keep the land, keep farming it, and get paid.

That's a property right in action: your choice, your compensation, nobody else's well paying for it.

The neighbor is a property owner too. Their well, their road, their view, their tax bill and their night sky are part of their bundle. Defending those things isn't anti-property. It's the most pro-property position there is.

If caring what happens next door makes someone a NIMBY, then property law has been NIMBY since the Middle Ages.

Selling is their business. Rezoning is everyone's. A Comprehensive Plan Amendment changes the County's public plan, which is exactly why it goes through public hearings and a vote of elected officials. When a decision sends thousands of daily car trips onto shared roads and new demand onto a shared aquifer, the people who share them get a say.

Residential growth brings revenue and it brings costs: schools, roads, public safety, water and sewer. Whether a project pays its own way depends on the specific application, its proffers and its infrastructure. Ask for the fiscal impact analysis. If nobody can show you one, that's your answer.

What Virginia law actually says

Zoning exists to protect property, not to punish it

Virginia law (Code of Virginia ยง 15.2-2283) says zoning ordinances exist to promote the health, safety and general welfare of the public. Among the purposes the General Assembly lists:

  • Providing adequate light, air and convenience of access
  • Protecting against overcrowding of land
  • Preventing undue density relative to available community facilities
  • Reducing danger and congestion in travel
  • Supporting adequate water, schools, parks and public safety

Read that list again. Every item protects someone's ability to enjoy what they own. Zoning is the neighbors' property rights, written down in advance.

"A nuisance may be merely a right thing in the wrong place, like a pig in the parlor instead of the barnyard."
U.S. Supreme Court, Village of Euclid v. Ambler Realty Co. (1926), upholding local zoning

Nobody is against pigs. Nobody is against houses. The question is always: is this the right place? That question belongs to the whole community, not just the seller.

Get involved

Stand up for property rights. Yours and next door's.

1

Know the application

Look up the Comprehensive Plan Amendment or rezoning case number, read the staff report, and ask for the fiscal and traffic analysis.

2

Show up

Planning Commission and Board of County Supervisors hearings take public comment. Three minutes from a neighbor carries real weight. pwcva.gov

3

Back a plan

Tell the Board you support planning the rural Gainesville District as a whole (Item 12-D) before more rural CPAs move forward. Rural landowners: look into the County's voluntary PDR program.

Learn more from people doing the work